For a political program that likes to keep cue usoverandoverandoveragain that it pry our individual privateness , Facebook ’s done a pretty piss - poor job of actually follow through . Over the past few calendar month , we ’ve understand the companypurposefully preventany of us from opting out of this sort of data - mining motorcar , while lateraccidentally sharingthat data with thousands of developer — both locallyand abroad . Now , it looks like the data - vacuum-clean heavyweight is trying to weasel out of not only its promises to consumers , but the assurances it made to regulators , too .
This news total from Bloomberg , whichfirst reportedthat Facebook was attempt to push back against Ireland ’s Data Protection Commission — the de factonational authorityresponsible for apply datum - protection laws across the total EU . Earlier this calendar week , the Wall Street Journal reported that these Irish authorities broadcast Facebook apreliminary orderasking that the company stop sending the data of European citizens back to the society ’s Silicon Valley HQ , or hazard a multibillion - buck fine from local say-so .
To back up a mo , Ireland is n’t acting alone here . Its rules of order total not long after the total Court Justice of the European Unionofficially invalidateda set of longstanding rules , known as the Privacy Shield , meant to ensurethat the data of EU citizen could be safely confine on the server of U.S.-based tech troupe like Facebook and Google without the federal authorities get under one’s skin its work force on it . Without any meaningful alternative to the Shield , companies like Facebook are left trying to show to EU regulator that they can be responsible for EU users ’ data — and without the legislative hope that riddle them with some level of trust that they enjoyed until now .
Photo: Loic Venance (Getty Images)
But when labour against a wall by the Irish regulator , Facebook did n’t reach into its usual grip of tricks : It did n’t downplay its ties to the always - mess about , all - Americandragnet , launch intoincredibly flimsyfacades about its attention for consumer choice , orpoint any fingersat China . alternatively , it just head out that the proposal of marriage to keep the EU ’s datum off of Facebook ’s American host would be bad for business .
“ A deficiency of safe , secure and sound outside data transfers would damage the economic system and halter the emergence of datum - driven businesses in the EU , just as we seek a recovery from COVID-19 , ” Facebook ’s VP of Global Affairs , Nick Clegg , say in ablog postearlier this hebdomad .
“ The impact would be felt by businesses big and small , across multiple sectors . In the bad case scenario , this could imply that a small technical school start up in Germany would no longer be able to employ a US - based cloud provider . A Spanish product development company could no longer be able to run an operation across multiple time zones . A French retailer may find they can no longer maintain a call kernel in Morocco . ”
Facebook ’s no alien to using lowly businesses as amakeshift shieldwhen it ’s looking to sidestep some weighty regulation or curry favour among the party trying to cash in one’s chips them . But none of these imaginary outside caller are the topic of the EU guard dog ’s choler right now — Facebook is . And Facebook , even in the best - case scenario , has a lot of money on the line here . If it does n’t want to constantly fork over a percentage of its tax income in mulct to the European government , it needs to make a honest - faith effort to actually cut off these transatlantic data flows from the roughly400 millon Facebookersbased in the part .
Because “ data ” is kind of asquishy term , technically everything from rent protocol to cloud service would need to be upended under Ireland ’s proposal , since these sorts of Job often execute the risk of infection storing some variety of data point from the EU in one of Facebook ’s servers . And as the Journalpoints out , these same stipulations could easily be floated to just about every other major tech company , even if Facebook fight back . And like Facebook also pointed out , take this stipulation one stone’s throw too far has the potentiality to all upendtrillions of dollarsexpected to pass between the U.S. and EU digital food market this year . And considering how our patronage deals with the region have grownkinda frostyunder Trump ’s tenure , it ’s safe to say that this variety of shock to our e - saving is the last matter we really involve mightily now .
Granted , all of this is the bad - case scenario . Ireland ’s data watchdog gift Facebook until “ mid - September ” to respond to the order , as sources close to the business deal told Bloomberg . Once they do , the mission plans to mail out a young draft of the order to the 26 other data government agency across the EU for “ joint approval ” from all sides .
But the right way now , Facebook is n’t proposing any solution ; it ’s leave it to the EU to do up with a legislative solvent that meets privacy standard while also grant Facebook to institute data to its U.S. server . And as long as it demands that , it ’s admitting that it will always put profits over privacy .
FacebookPrivacy
Daily Newsletter
Get the best tech , science , and civilization news show in your inbox daily .
intelligence from the future , fork out to your present .
You May Also Like
